Sector averages can nearly triple Scope 3 estimates, Toyota supply chain study finds

Scope 3
Sector averages can nearly triple Scope 3 estimates, Toyota supply chain study finds
Photo by Lenny Kuhne on Unsplash

Applying sector-average emission factors to suppliers can nearly triple a company's upstream Scope 3 estimate. That is the central finding of a University of Groningen study of Toyota Motor Corporation's supply network, published in npj Environmental Social Sciences, which traced emissions across 9,948 suppliers in five tiers.

What did the study look at?

Zeyu Wang, Klaus Hubacek and Franco Ruzzenenti, of the Energy and Sustainability Research Institute Groningen, mapped Toyota's upstream supply network for 2023. They used commercial databases of supplier and customer relationships and company financials. Most trade values between firms are not published, so the authors estimated them from supplier sales, customer sales and distance. They then traced embodied emissions through the network tier by tier.

They ran the same network through four sets of emission intensities and changed nothing else.

How much did the choice of emission factor change the result?

  • Firm-level intensities (baseline): 12.4 million tonnes. The 4,124 suppliers that disclose emissions got their own intensities. The other 5,824 got subindustry averages.
  • Subindustry averages: 16.0 million tonnes, 29% above the baseline.
  • Sector averages from a commercial ESG data provider: 20.8 million tonnes, 68% above.
  • Sector averages from the EXIOBASE input-output database: 36.0 million tonnes, 190% above.

A sector average gives every firm in a sector the same intensity, so a supplier's footprint depends only on how much it sells. The authors found that about 80% of the largest emitters in Toyota's network ran below their sector average. They write that aggregated proxies "may obscure heterogeneity in suppliers' carbon performance and, as a consequence, inflate the overall footprint." The choice of database also changed the result: the two sector-average sources came out 15.2 million tonnes apart for the same network.

Where in the supply chain are the emissions?

Direct (Tier 1) suppliers accounted for 60% of upstream embodied emissions across the five tiers, and the first three tiers for 93%. Ten firms made up nearly 60% of the five-tier total. The largest was Toyota Tsusho, the Toyota Group's trading company, at about 13%. The authors recommend that Toyota prioritise deep engagement with its direct (Tier 1) suppliers.

How many suppliers disclose their emissions?

Of the 9,948 suppliers in the network, 4,124 disclose their Scope 1 and 2 emissions, which is roughly 40%. The relationship data identified 185 of Toyota's roughly 400 Tier 1 suppliers, and the authors say these account for more than 80% of procurement.

What are the study's limits?

The study covers one company, upstream emissions only, to five tiers. About 10% of the trade values in the network are reported figures, and the rest are modelled. The authors' estimate is lower than Toyota's own reported figure, which they attribute to incomplete supplier coverage. The code is not public because the underlying data is licensed.

What do the authors recommend?

They argue that mandating and incentivising improved granularity in corporate emissions disclosure is essential. They also warn that "climate regulations relying on sector-average benchmarks risk misallocation of mitigation effort and resources." Target-setting raises the same issue, which we cover in why averages will not be enough for SBTi V2.0 Scope 3 targets.

Sources

See the platform, or claim your profile

If you are working out what your suppliers and portfolio companies emit, we will show you what we already hold and where each figure came from.

If you are the one being asked for data, claim your organisation's profile and answer once instead of filling in the same form for every customer.