Transparent scorecard breakdown

DitchCarbon's supplier carbon scorecard shows every criterion behind an organisation's score, with the weight applied, the points earned out of the points available, the source consulted and the value found.

How is this supplier's scorecard actually calculated?

Criterion by criterion. Six groups cover industry, region, reporting, initiatives, reductions and reporting quality. Each row names the criterion, its weight, the points earned out of those available, the source consulted and the value found, for example a CDP database check returning disclosed. Filter to earned or unearned criteria.

The scorecard breakdown in the DitchCarbon portal, showing a criteria group with weight, points, source and value for each criterion.

A score a supplier cannot interrogate is a score they will argue with. Showing the criteria removes the argument: an organisation on 42 can see which rows scored zero and what evidence would change them.

The sources are named per row rather than in aggregate. An SBTi database lookup, a CDP response, a company disclosure and an assurance verification are different kinds of evidence, and the row says which one produced the value.

Filtering to unearned criteria turns the scorecard into an engagement list. Those rows are the specific, checkable things to ask an organisation for, rather than a general request to improve.

For procurement, the open criteria are what make the score usable in a sourcing decision. A buyer can say why a supplier scored 62 in an award review, and the supplier reads the same criteria on its own profile. Sustainable procurement shows the score beside spend in the systems buyers already run.

The published methodology sets out the groups and the weightings, so the score can be reconciled against it rather than taken on trust.

Old way
A number, and a supplier who wants to know where it came from.
new way
Every criterion, its weight, its source and its value.

Common questions

Can a supplier challenge its score?

They can check it, which is better. The breakdown names every criterion, its weight, the points available and the source that scored it, so a disagreement becomes a specific question about one row rather than an argument about the number.

Is the score auditable?

Every criterion is shown with the source consulted and the value found, so a score can be reconciled against the published methodology rather than accepted. Filtering to unearned criteria shows exactly which checks did not pass and what evidence would change them.

Available plans
Analyse
Action
Status
Live
Frameworks
SBTi
CDP
Last reviewed
November 3, 2026

See every criterion behind a supplier's score

Numbers you can defend within 2 weeks, or one profile that answers every buyer asking.